toolskoInstant Results. Privacy First.

Heating Fuel Cost Comparison: Gas, Propane, Oil, Heat Pump

Compare the real cost of heat from natural gas, propane, heating oil, electric heat and a heat pump, per million Btu and per year, with break-even prices.

Tool inputs stay in your browser · optional AI search sends your query

Good to know: Scope: the fuel cost of home heating in the U.S. for five systems — a natural gas, propane or heating oil furnace or boiler, electric resistance heat (electric furnace or baseboard) and an air-source heat pump — using the EIA method: price per unit ÷ heat content per unit × 1,000,000 = dollars per million Btu, then divided by the system’s efficiency to get the cost of heat actually delivered to your home. Heat content values are the EIA sample conversion factors (natural gas 1,036 Btu per cubic foot and 100,000 Btu per therm, propane 91,452 Btu per gallon, heating oil 138,500 Btu per gallon, electricity 3,412 Btu per kWh); a therm on your gas bill may already be adjusted for your gas’s actual heat content. Furnace efficiency is the AFUE on the yellow EnergyGuide label (DOE: older systems 56% to 70%, mid-efficiency 80% to 83%, high-efficiency 90% to 98.5%); heat pump efficiency is the HSPF2 rating (heating Btu per watt-hour). Default prices are U.S. averages from EIA — propane $2.826 and heating oil $5.915 a gallon (week of November 9, 2026), natural gas $14.95 per thousand cubic feet ($1.495 per Ccf, February 2026) and electricity 18.16¢ per kWh (August 2026) — type your own prices from your bills for a real answer. If you enter what you spend on heating in a year, the tool estimates the heat your home uses and the yearly cost of the same heat with each fuel, plus break-even prices. Not included: buying and installing equipment, fixed monthly customer charges, delivery fees, tank rental, minimum orders, maintenance, rebates and tax credits, wood, wood pellets, kerosene and coal, geothermal heat pumps, cooling, duct losses, and price changes during the winter. Nothing you type is sent or saved. A fuel-cost estimate, not a quote. Sources reviewed November 16, 2026.

How to use it (step by step)

  1. 1Type the prices you pay: natural gas (pick per Ccf, per therm or per Mcf, as shown on your bill), propane and heating oil per gallon, and electricity in cents per kWh (your total bill ÷ kWh used gives a good all-in price). Leave a price empty to skip that fuel.
  2. 2Check the efficiencies: the AFUE of each furnace or boiler (on its label or in the manual) and the HSPF2 of the heat pump. Keep the defaults if you do not know them.
  3. 3Optional: pick your current heating and enter what you spend on it in a year. Then read the cheapest option, the cost per million Btu of heat for each, your yearly cost with each fuel, your possible savings and the break-even prices.

Words to know

Million Btu (MMBtu)
A British thermal unit (Btu) is the heat needed to warm 1 pound of water by 1°F. Comparing fuels per million Btu puts gallons, therms and kWh on the same scale.
AFUE
Annual fuel utilization efficiency: the share of a furnace or boiler’s fuel that becomes heat for your home over a year. 90% AFUE means 90 cents of every fuel dollar heats the house.
HSPF2
Heating seasonal performance factor: how many Btu of heat a heat pump gives over a season for each watt-hour of electricity. ENERGY STAR split systems need at least 7.8.
Therm and Ccf
A therm is 100,000 Btu of gas. A Ccf is 100 cubic feet of gas, about 103,600 Btu at the EIA average of 1,036 Btu per cubic foot. An Mcf is 1,000 cubic feet.

Explore tools for Australia, the US & Europe →

Sources & methods

References checked November 11, 2026. Read each tool’s scope and assumptions before relying on its result.

Spotted a wrong result or an outdated rule? Report a mistake · How we check our tools · Get new tools by email

Related tools

See all tools in the Home Energy & Electricity Bills →